Marc Lou bans a MailCheap sender after opens fall to 3%
A blocklisted link and an 8% bounce rate, then two warnings ignored.
Marc Lou says he banned a customer from MailCheap after their Gmail open rate collapsed from 32% to 9% to 3% across a run of sends. In his post he lays out the sequence as a six step recipe for landing in spam. The customer linked to a domain on Spamhaus's blocklist, mailed a dusty old list that bounced at 8%, got their campaign paused and a warning from Lou, then did it again.
My customers who follow the rules averaged 31% opens at Gmail.
The comparison number is the part worth writing down. Lou says customers who follow the rules averaged 31% opens at Gmail. Same product, same infrastructure, roughly ten times the open rate, and the only variable he names is what the sender did to their own list.
Why the ban matters to other senders
Email providers share reputation. One account hammering Gmail with bounces and blocklisted links does not just hurt itself, which is the context for a post from @salbareesh the same week claiming MailCheap customers were landing in spam. Lou's reply, effectively, is that the bad sender is the problem and he removed them.
That is also the uncomfortable bit for anyone running a sending product. You can build the thing, but your deliverability is partly held hostage by your worst customer, and the only fix is policing them. Lou paused the campaign first and warned the customer before banning, so the ladder is pause, warn, remove.
The business read
Deliverability is not a feature you buy, it is list hygiene you maintain, and the penalty is not a bounce message, it is your opens quietly sliding over a few sends until nobody reads you. An 8% bounce rate on an old list is the tell. A link to a blocklisted domain is the other one. Both are things the sender controls before they hit send.
MailCheap is Lou's email product, and he has been posting its numbers in public as it grows, including a jump to $2k MRR six days after it crossed $1k. Banning a paying customer at that size is not nothing. It suggests he reads the reputation of the shared sending pool as worth more than one subscription, which is the same calculation every email provider eventually makes.
One caveat. These are Lou's own numbers from his own dashboard, reported in a post, not an audited study. The 31% average for compliant customers is his figure and nobody else has published it.
The emails of people who use Mailcheap are landing in spam.
Steal the numbers, not the vibes
One email a day. Under three minutes. Real MRR, real pricing, real launches from founders building with AI.

